Can You Fail a C&P Exam? What Veterans Need to Know
"Can I fail my C&P exam?" is one of the most common questions veterans ask before their appointment. The anxiety behind this question is understandable. Your disability rating and the benefits tied to it can depend heavily on what happens during this single medical evaluation.
The short answer is no, you cannot technically fail a C&P exam. It is not a test with a passing or failing grade. But that simple answer misses what veterans are really worried about, which is whether the exam can go badly enough to hurt their claim. And the honest answer to that question is yes, it can. Understanding C&P exam outcomes and your options when things do not go well is essential for protecting your claim.
The Examiner Does Not Decide Your Rating: The C&P examiner documents findings and provides a medical opinion. A separate VA rating specialist reviews the entire claim file, including the exam report, medical records, buddy statements, and all other evidence, before making the rating decision.
What C&P Exam Outcomes Actually Look Like
Instead of pass or fail, C&P exams produce examiner findings that fall into three general categories.
Favorable Outcomes
A favorable exam includes a confirmed diagnosis of your claimed condition, thorough documentation of symptom severity and functional limitations, a positive nexus opinion stating your condition is "at least as likely as not" connected to military service, and findings that are consistent with your reported symptoms and medical records.
Unfavorable Outcomes
An unfavorable exam may include the examiner stating you do not currently have the claimed condition, documenting only minimal severity, providing a nexus opinion that the condition is "less likely than not" related to service, or noting that your condition does not significantly affect your daily functioning.
Incomplete or Inconclusive Exams
Sometimes the exam is neither clearly favorable nor unfavorable. The examiner may state they cannot provide an opinion without additional information, not all claimed conditions may have been addressed, or findings may be documented without a clear severity assessment. These situations typically result in the VA ordering a second exam or requesting more evidence.
What a 0% Rating Really Means
Many veterans who receive a 0% rating think they failed their exam. This is a misunderstanding that causes a lot of frustration.
A 0% rating means the VA acknowledges your condition IS service-connected. That is a significant finding. It means:
- The VA recognizes the connection between your condition and your military service
- You are eligible for VA healthcare for that condition
- The condition is in your official VA records
- You can file for an increase later if the condition worsens
- It counts in your combined disability rating calculation
0% Is Not a Denial: A 0% rating and a denial are completely different outcomes. A denial means the VA says the condition is not service-connected at all. A 0% rating means the VA agrees it is service-connected but currently does not meet the minimum severity for compensable benefits. A 0% rating is a foundation you can build on.
Why 0% Ratings Happen
- The condition exists but symptoms are currently mild
- Treatment effectively manages the condition
- Symptoms do not yet meet the specific criteria for a 10% rating in the VA's rating schedule
- The condition is present but not producing significant functional impairment at the time of the exam
Increasing From 0%
If you believe your 0% rating should be higher, you have options:
- File a claim for increase with new medical evidence showing greater severity or frequency
- Submit a private DBQ from your treating physician documenting more significant symptoms
- File a Supplemental Claim with new evidence
- Request a Higher-Level Review if you believe the rating specialist made an error
When Claims Get Denied
While you cannot fail the exam itself, unfavorable C&P exam results can contribute to claim denials. The most common reasons claims are denied after a C&P exam:
No current diagnosis: The examiner could not confirm you have the claimed condition. This sometimes happens when conditions are intermittent, when the exam catches you on a good day, or when the examiner applies overly strict diagnostic criteria.
Unfavorable nexus opinion: The examiner states the condition is not related to your military service. This can happen when service treatment records do not clearly document the injury, when there is a long gap between service and diagnosis, or when the examiner does not have enough information to form a favorable opinion.
Insufficient evidence: The overall evidence in your claim file, including the C&P exam findings, does not support service connection or the level of severity you claimed.
Missed appointment: You did not show up for the scheduled exam, which typically results in the claim being decided based on whatever evidence exists in the file, often leading to denial.
What You Can Do After a Bad Exam
If your C&P exam did not go well, you are not without options. Acting quickly matters.
Before the VA Makes Its Decision
Submit a written statement to your claim explaining what the examiner missed, what symptoms were not documented, and what you believe was inaccurate in the exam. Be specific and factual.
Provide additional medical evidence from your treating physicians. Recent treatment records showing ongoing symptoms can counter a C&P exam that underreported severity.
Get a private DBQ completed by your own doctor. A thorough DBQ from a qualified provider who knows your condition can serve as powerful contradictory evidence. This is especially effective when the private DBQ comes from a specialist who has treated you over time.
After an Unfavorable Decision
Supplemental Claim: File with new and relevant evidence the VA has not previously considered. This is the recommended path for most veterans because you can submit the private DBQ, additional medical records, and buddy statements that address the weaknesses in the C&P exam.
Higher-Level Review: A senior VA reviewer examines the same evidence. This is appropriate when you believe the rating specialist made an error in interpreting the C&P exam results or failed to follow VA regulations. The reviewer can determine the exam was inadequate and order a new one.
Board of Veterans' Appeals: A Veterans Law Judge reviews your case. You can submit new evidence and request a hearing. This takes longer (12 to 18 months) but involves a thorough, independent review.
One-Year Deadline: You have one year from the date of your decision to file an appeal and preserve your original effective date. Missing this deadline does not prevent you from filing, but you lose the retroactive back pay to your original filing date.
Preventing Unfavorable Outcomes
The best strategy is preventing bad exam outcomes in the first place:
Before the exam: Submit strong medical evidence with your initial claim. Include buddy statements. Ensure your service records clearly document in-service injuries or diagnoses. Consider getting a private DBQ before the C&P exam to supplement whatever the VA examiner documents.
During the exam: Bring documentation the examiner may not have. Describe symptoms specifically, including worst-day scenarios. Explain functional limitations with concrete examples. Make sure all claimed conditions are examined before you leave. Do not minimize your symptoms or push through pain during physical testing.
After the exam: Document everything that happened while your memory is fresh. Request a copy of the exam report. If you notice problems, submit a statement immediately and consider obtaining a private DBQ.
When an Unfavorable Result May Be Accurate
Sometimes unfavorable exam outcomes accurately reflect the current state of the evidence. If your service records do not document the incident, if there is a long gap between service and diagnosis without any treatment records bridging the gap, or if your condition genuinely does not meet VA disability criteria, the examiner's opinion may be medically sound.
In these cases, the path forward is building stronger evidence over time: continuing treatment, obtaining a detailed nexus letter from a qualified provider, and gathering buddy statements from people who witnessed the in-service event or your ongoing struggles.
The Key Takeaway
You cannot fail a C&P exam, but the exam can produce unfavorable findings that hurt your claim. The difference between a favorable and unfavorable outcome usually comes down to preparation: arriving with documentation, communicating your symptoms honestly and specifically, describing your worst days, and making sure every claimed condition gets properly evaluated.
Even if an exam does go poorly, you have multiple paths to correct the record. The VA disability claims system gives you several opportunities to present your case through additional evidence, appeals, and new exams.
How the Benefits Finder Helps
Your C&P exam shapes your disability rating, and your rating determines which benefits are available to you. Understanding the full scope of benefits at stake helps you take the right steps to protect your claim.
Use the Veterans Benefits Finder to see every federal and state benefit available at your current or expected disability rating.
Next Step: Complete your benefits profile to see the complete picture of benefits available to you. Whether you are preparing for your first C&P exam or recovering from an unfavorable one, knowing what is at stake motivates the right next step.
Related Articles
Common C&P Exam Mistakes That Cost Veterans Their Rating
Learn the most frequent mistakes veterans make during C&P exams that lead to lower ratings or denials, and exactly how to avoid each one.
C&P Exam Preparation Checklist: Everything You Need Before Your VA Exam
A step-by-step preparation checklist for your VA C&P exam. Know what documents to bring, how to prepare mentally, and the timeline for getting ready.
C&P Exams by Condition Type: What to Expect for Your Specific Claim
Detailed breakdown of what happens during C&P exams for PTSD, orthopedic injuries, TBI, hearing loss, sleep apnea, and other common conditions veterans claim.
DBQ vs C&P Exam: Understanding the Difference and When to Use Each
Learn the key differences between private Disability Benefits Questionnaires and VA C&P exams, when each is most useful, typical costs, and how to use both strategically.